Heart failure is increasingly common. An estimated five million patients in the United States suffer from chronic heart failure, and an additional 500,000 new cases are diagnosed annually.
Although rest was traditionally recommended, many patients often remained burdened by fatigue, diminished exercise tolerance, poor quality of life, recurrent hospitalizations and early mortality. Several studies have assessed the ability of exercise training to improve functional capacity in patients with heart failure and have observed relatively few complications during training.
Cathy Johns talked with Dr. Dalynn Badenhop.
The University of Toledo Medical Center cardiac rehabilitation program participated in a National Institutes of Health study titled “Heart Failure: A Controlled Trial Investigating Outcomes of Exercise Training.” The randomized, controlled trial featured 2,331 medically stable outpatients with heart failure at 82 participating centers in the United States, Canada and France.
The study was undertaken to determine whether aerobic-type exercise training reduces mortality and hospitalization, and improves quality of life in patients with medically stable chronic heart failure when administered in addition to usual care.
Dr. Dalynn Badenhop, director of cardiac rehabilitation and professor of medicine, was UTMC’s principal investigator, and the late Dr. Thomas Walsh was UTMC’s chronic heart failure cardiologist for the study. Other UTMC health care personnel involved in the study were nurses Katie Roberts and Sandra Gardam, and exercise physiologists Abby Steigerwalt and Angie Petree.
The main results of study, which was published in the Journal of the American Medical Association in 2009, showed that patients in the cardiac rehab group experienced modest to significant reductions in mortality and hospitalization, a significant reduction in cardiovascular mortality, and a significant reduction in heart failure hospitalizations compared to the usual care group.
In February 2014, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services approved coverage for cardiac rehabilitation services for beneficiaries with a diagnosis of chronic heart failure. Several studies have shown notable improvements in physical function, symptoms, psychological health, recurrent hospitalizations and death. Guidelines and policies from other countries have recommended cardiac rehabilitation coverage for chronic heart failure patients since 2010.
The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services stated the following in its decision memo: “Cardiac rehabilitation improves symptoms of chronic heart failure, decreases mortality and reduces hospitalizations. We conclude that the evidence that supports the clinical benefits of the individual components of cardiac rehab programs is sufficient to determine that participation in these programs improves health outcomes for Medicare beneficiaries with chronic heart failure.”
Cathy Johns, a patient in the UTMC Phase II cardiac rehab program, was one of the first to benefit from the centers’ decision to cover cardiac rehab for chronic heart failure patients.
“I was on vacation and I thought I was having a heart attack, but it turned out to be heart failure. The UTMC staff noticed some unexpected symptoms and discovered a virus that was attacking my heart and other vital organs,” Johns said. “I am still here because of their magnificent work and diligence. I owe my life to UTMC, that’s no exaggeration.”
“In the 1980s, we wouldn’t have considered cardiac rehabilitation an appropriate therapy for patients like Cathy. We didn’t know enough about the beneficial effects. After 25 years of research, we now have the proof that these programs have merit,” Badenhop said.
“I didn’t exercise at all before I got sick,” Johns said. “I can’t imagine not having a program like this to monitor my progress and help further heal my heart.”
During one of her final cardiac rehab sessions, Johns completed 72 minutes of exercise.
“Cathy showed great improvement over time. She started with the ability to walk 2,700 feet in 12 minutes, and she can now walk more than 3,100 feet in 12 minutes,” Badenhop said. “Ultimately, the goal of cardiac rehab is to improve the patient’s quality of life. Numbers and statistics are great, but those improved numbers need to transfer to the patient’s daily activities.”
Johns was concerned that she would never be able to attend another Detroit Tigers game due to complications from chronic heart failure. Since going through UTMC’s cardiac rehab program, she was able to see her favorite team in action without incident.
“It was an incredible experience,” Johns said. “I was able to walk around the park and get to and from my seat without any issues.”
Johns has chosen to enroll in the Phase III maintenance program to continue the healing process. Phase III is similar to a gym membership, but with the added benefit of being in a medically monitored setting.
“I was worried about the cost, but it’s as affordable as being a member at a traditional gym. It’s the best investment I could hope to make,” Johns said.
“For chronic heart failure patients, UTMC is the place to be,” Badenhop said.
For more information about UTMC’s Heart and Vascular Center, visit utmc.utoledo.edu/clinics/hvc.